Never discount the value of extra time…EONIA to €STR move delayed to 27 July

17 April 2020

Phil LloydHead of Market Structure & Regulatory Customer Engagement

View bio

Other insights

View more insights

7 minute read

On the 17 April the LCH1 announced a 5 week delay to 27 July for the move from EONIA2 to €STR3 discounting for cleared trades due to concerns over operational risks created by COVID-19.  We expect Eurex and CME4 to follow suit.

The CCPs5, the ECB6 and the members of the clearing houses have been struggling with whether in the light of all the disruption caused by the Coronavirus, it was still right to go ahead with the switch on the previously agreed date of 22 June.  The ECB ran a survey of the EU RFR7 working group members to poll opinions, but the results were inconclusive. Notwithstanding this, LCH has decided upon a short delay to 27 July to ensure "a safe transition with the minimum of operational risks". 

The balancing act...op risk, swaptions and SOFR8

It is a balancing act between the risk of going sooner (ie June) when so many are still likely to be working from home (and operational, technology and front office staff are stretched) versus delaying, and potentially crowding up against the Fed Funds to SOFR discounting switch in October, creating delivery risk there. In the end a compromise of moving in July was reached, allowing a bit more time for preparation while not getting too close to the US date.

The issue is further clouded by a heated debate around swaptions.  Swaptions are generally priced as if they were to settle via cleared swaps, meaning that they will use the discounting curves in use by CCPs at the point they are exercised. If those swaptions were entered into under the expectation of a different discounting curve, then there is a valuation difference and a case for an agreed compensation between the parties. 

Since the end of March a new flag 'Agreed Discount Rate' has been added to confirmations, meaning there is now no doubt which discounting curve was used when entering into the swaption. The market convention since then has been to populate with €STR if expiring after 22 June, EONIA if before that.

But that leaves two areas of uncertainty:  1) will there be a compensation mechanism and how will it work?; and 2) assuming yes, what population of trades will it apply to?   Since the end of March we can say with certainty that new trades expiring after 22 June are with €STR discounting, though CCP settlement will only match that now from 27 July.  And pre September 2019 they were EONIA and some compensation may be due. The debate is around the population in the middle. 

The change to the CCP date from June to July adds some further operational complexity, as swaption trades entered since the end of March (using €STR) and expiring before the new switch date, would have a payout that diverges from the price of the underlying cleared swap (as cleared swaps as of this date would still use EONIA discounting). There is a consultation from ECB on the compensation mechanism where closing date was extended to 17 April (the ARRCconsultation closed on 9 March).

See the timeline below of the key dates linked to the swaption question:   

Whatever the pros & cons of the alternatives, the CCPs have now at least made a decision, and gone with a short delay to July.

And that leaves the bi-lateral market...  

The assumption has always been that the bi-lateral market would try broadly to follow the timing set by the CCPs for cleared.  Ideally you don't want the cleared and non-cleared markets discounting off different curves given one tends to offset the other, though that basis can be managed by trading desks over a short time period.

So with July now the cleared date, expect an uptick in communications from counterparties asking what your plans are for changing CSAs10 to discounting based on €STR flat.  That is an operational challenge in its own right that will place further pressures on organisations. 

The switch is intended to be economically neutral, with changes in MTM11 valuations caused by the 8.5 bps12 change from EONIA to €STR offset by a compensating fee payment.  But that still means agreeing a valuation, amending trades and issuing the payments, which could be quite a challenge between organisations with large bi-lateral portfolios (again with everyone working from home).

SOFR move is the elephant in the room

CME and other CCPs plan to move discounting from Fed Funds to SOFR on 16 October.  This is seen as a critical step in building liquidity in SOFR, and therefore the overall transition path for USD LIBOR13 as well (and indeed for the cross currency market).  For many October is already late (in terms of USD14 transition), so there would be resistance to moving that date out (not that that has been suggested yet).  But the FF15 to SOFR switch is much more complicated than the EONIA to €STR flat one, as both rates are floating, and the compensation mechanism will be more complex.

For more information on the background to the discounting changes see the summary from ISDA16 in their 2020 RFR Major Developments paper (pp 11-13), the detailed LCH transition plans (for SwapClear members and clients only) and the CME pages for €STR and SOFR.  

So what do we think?

Well this is a balancing act.  We were concerned about the risks in June, but would have been worried about October if June had become September.  The move to July buys some time while avoiding that risk (albeit with a minor additional headache for swaptions exercising during those 5 weeks).

Normally market participants would avoid large transition events in the middle of the holiday season, but with COVID upsetting all those plans anyway that is perhaps less of a concern this year. 

So far, per recent BoE17 announcement, the LIBOR end-2021 date has not moved so pushing interim milestones too much to the right might lead to some bigger problems down the line.  

The reality is that in the current crisis there are no perfect answers and we can't let perfect get in the way of DONE.

Additional contributing author: John Stevenson-Hamilton

Footnotes

  1. LCH – London Clearing House
  2. EONIA – Euro Overnight Index Average
  3. €STR – Euro short-term rate
  4. CME – Chicago Mercantile Exchange
  5. CCPs – Central Counterparty Clearing House
  6. ECB – European Central Bank
  7. RFR – Risk-Free Rates
  8. SOFR – Secured Overnight Financing Rate
  9. ARRC – Alternative Reference Rates Committee
  10. CSA – Credit Support Annex
  11. MTM – Mark to Market
  12. bps – basis points
  13. LIBOR – London Inter-Bank Offered Rate
  14. USD – US dollar
  15. FF – Fed Funds
  16. ISDA – International Swaps and Derivatives Association
  17. BoE - Bank of England
Regulation
EONIA
ESTR
LCH
Markets
Regulation clearing


This document has been prepared for information purposes only, does not constitute an analysis of all potentially material issues and is subject to change at any time without prior notice. NatWest Markets does not undertake to update you of such changes.  It is indicative only and is not binding. Other than as indicated, this document has been prepared on the basis of publicly available information believed to be reliable but no representation, warranty, undertaking or assurance of any kind, express or implied, is made as to the adequacy, accuracy, completeness or reasonableness of the information contained in this document, nor does NatWest Markets accept any obligation to any recipient to update or correct any information contained herein. Views expressed herein are not intended to be and should not be viewed as advice or as a personal recommendation. The views expressed herein may not be objective or independent of the interests of the authors or other NatWest Markets trading desks, who may be active participants in the markets, investments or strategies referred to in this document. NatWest Markets will not act and has not acted as your legal, tax, regulatory, accounting or investment adviser; nor does NatWest Markets owe any fiduciary duties to you in connection with this, and/or any related transaction and no reliance may be placed on NatWest Markets for investment advice or recommendations of any sort. You should make your own independent evaluation of the relevance and adequacy of the information contained in this document and any issues that are of concern to you.

This document does not constitute an offer to buy or sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell any investment, nor does it constitute an offer to provide any products or services that are capable of acceptance to form a contract. NatWest Markets and each of its respective affiliates accepts no liability whatsoever for any direct, indirect or consequential losses (in contract, tort or otherwise) arising from the use of this material or reliance on the information contained herein. However this shall not restrict, exclude or limit any duty or liability to any person under any applicable laws or regulations of any jurisdiction which may not be lawfully disclaimed.

NatWest Markets Plc. Incorporated and registered in Scotland No. 90312 with limited liability. Registered Office: 36 St Andrew Square, Edinburgh EH2 2YB. Authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and Prudential Regulation Authority. NatWest Markets N.V. is incorporated with limited liability in the Netherlands, authorised and regulated by De Nederlandsche Bank and the Autoriteit Financiële Markten. It has its seat at Amsterdam, the Netherlands, and is registered in the Commercial Register under number 33002587. Registered Office: Claude Debussylaan 94, Amsterdam, the Netherlands. Branch Reg No. in England BR001029. NatWest Markets Plc is, in certain jurisdictions, an authorised agent of NatWest Markets N.V. and NatWest Markets N.V. is, in certain jurisdictions, an authorised agent of NatWest Markets Plc. NatWest Markets Securities Japan Limited [Kanto Financial Bureau (Kin-sho) No. 202] is authorised and regulated by the Japan Financial Services Agency. Securities business in the United States is conducted through NatWest Markets Securities Inc., a FINRA registered broker-dealer (http://www.finra.org), a SIPC member (www.sipc.org) and a wholly owned indirect subsidiary of NatWest Markets Plc.

Copyright 2020 © NatWest Markets Plc. All rights reserved.